
Failing Forward
The story is driven by both the players' successes and failures. Every time the dice are rolled, it affects the unfolding story. When players face skill checks without opposition and don't meet the required difficulty, the story doesn't stop. Instead, it takes a new direction, creating opportunities for new adventures and plot twists. This principle reflects the game's philosophy: every outcome, good or bad, presents a chance for storytelling.
In Enigma, failure doesn't mean the end of the story. Each challenge that isn't overcome directly influences the story's progression, sometimes leading to unexpected developments or problems. Failing a Navigate check doesn't necessarily mean being unable to pass an obstacle; it could also alert enemies, creating more tension and urgency. Not spotting an ambush through a failed Glean check might accidentally reveal important clues about the attackers, adding depth to the story. Failures can still move players closer to their goals, but with unforeseen consequences, making the journey more challenging and nuanced.
Example:
Player: "I wish to persuade the sentry to ignore our presence and leave the gate unsecured for us".
Game Master: "Challenging, given the sentry's loyalty. Attempt an Influence capacity check against their Glean die".
Player: Rolls a 6.
Game Master: Sentry rolls an 8. "The sentry isn't swayed to abandon his duties but finds your boldness noteworthy. 'Can't let you through without a proper cause,' he murmurs, 'but if you aid me with a personal dilemma, perhaps the gate might unlatch itself later".
Player: "Let's delve into this dilemma of yours.”
Emphasize to your players that setbacks are not only hindrances but narrative catalysts, ensuring the story continuously evolves. When navigating the outcomes of failed actions, aim for imaginative yet fair consequences, keeping the game engaging and players motivated to take risks. Foster a game environment where players feel encouraged to contribute to the narrative direction following a setback. This collaborative approach deepens engagement and paves the way for creative storytelling.